I stayed at the City Club hotel for the first-time mid Feb 2024. I stay in NYC often. I am adding City Club to my list of preferred hotels. The location is very convenient to midtown, where I typically like to be. Close to times square, major museums and the theater district. The hotel is older than others, but has few amenities you do not typically see. I had the smallest room, but restroom had a bidet and black marble.
There were a lot of details you would see in a more expensive hotel. The was a full mini bar and complimentary continental breakfast. I need to try one on the larger rooms the next time I am in NYC.
Some of the finishes were dated, but the hotel was clean, and the service was fantastic.