"Most things at this hotel worked out well but I don't think it was as comparable to other 9.2+ ratings I've stayed at. I thought it was more of a 8.8-9.0 ish. Or perhaps Kamakura hotels are just overall less competitive than Tokyo or Kyoto's.
While most factors are great - helpful staff, location not far from train station and walkable to shopping areas, clean rooms, public large bathing house, manga available in the lobby, nice night gown and towels in rooms. Some small details are not perfect - the windows only have a paper-like blinder, no black-out curtain, so for sleepers sensitive to light, you'd get woken up by sunlight as soon as the morning gets bright. Sound proofing is also not the best on the floors, I kept hearing people above us walking around the rooms in the morning and at night."