Find hotels in Fishers Island, NY from ₩98,236

"Great stay, great staff."

"Nice rooms, great staff, close to everything."

"Great location and cheap!!!"

"The restaurant and bar were excellent the food was good and the drinks were awesome!"

"Great location for the event that was attended"

"We had a last minute change on a holiday weekend when our original hotel booking was unexpectedly closed for repairs. The Hampton inn was further away but they were very accommodating with the last minute booking. Friendly staff, decent breakfast, clean room, well kept facilities."

"The room was okay."

"Hotel was clean and staff were friendly!"

"Rooms were very clean and breakfast offered a lot of food choices."

"I love to visit my friends there. The room is clean and the staff are very pleasant and helpful"

"Everything was great, room, breakfast, the outdoor pool. Second time staying here."

"Been staying in Gold Star Inn & Suites, for last 4 years..always a very pleasant stay, the lady & her husband are very friendly & helpful, The rooms are very clean & very large, the value is very good, Location is good as well. Can't wait to stay there again, With many thanks to the awesome staff, Nancy"

"Amenities were great, staff were friendly and helpful, the hot tub and pool were great. Breakfast was great as well!"

"Great"

"Easy access to major attractions !"

"Perfect location and amenities!"

"Great place to stay!"

"It was clean and the staff helpful."

"The hotel is great, always stay here when I’m in the area."

"Good value for money. We stayed 9 days in total and felt very confortable and safe. Room, fridge, microwave, and sheets were clean. Room interior also looks nice."