Find hotels near Tusten Theatre, Narrowsburg from ₩146,635

"They graciously accommodated by dog and we were able to stay in the barn. Super spacious, and the bed was really comfortable. Breakfast was awesome, made to order :) The staff were awesome!! I had a small medical emergency, and they were extremely supportive. Above and beyond :) Definitely coming again and bringing my family. "

"The Staff were extremely kind, The little shop was quaint. The outside surrounding was eh. The room itself was a no thrills room and was tiny. It had new vinyl floors which was nice. But the bathroom was not updated at all. The bed was comfy. And the heat worked great, it got cold the night i stayed."

"It’s outdated. New owners aren’t upgrading the facility, Evening entertainment is boring. The place was exciting when Doc was in charge of the activities. He kept it fun."

"Very clean, friendly quaint place. Beautiful restful stay!! I highly recommend!!!"

"Property was clean perfect, breakfast was great everything was fresh !!"

"I have been around the Lake Wally/Hawley + area for 40yrs (first owning a small summer place on the lake & as a local camp nurse for 20yrs), I always wanted to stay at Settlers--dined there many times--visited the gift shop, even looked into the rooms--finally got the chance--Wonder/Beautiful/Tranquil/Unique!!!"

"Beautiful place & very convenient to Bethel Woods!"

"Really a fantastic place. Extremely friendly staff that goes out of their way to may your stay enjoyable. Loved the views and waking up to the sound of the cascading waterfall, the large common room with a fireplace and balconies over the stream. Highly recommended. "

"Staff was very helpful, room was very comfortable, location turned out to be inconvenient for activities "

"The hotel is an older building with nothing fancy but clean and a great staff."

"My partner and I travel for business from time to time and he and I really enjoyed staying here. It was extremely peaceful and cute with a vintage vibe. The owner Kathy was very helpful and kind. It was also so nice to hear the river from our room and to spend some time in nature. The room was clean and comfortable. We were able to get good rest while on our work trip. If we are back in the area we will definitely book here again. "

"We enjoyed our stay at this Victorian B&B. The bed was comfortable, the room was warm and cozy and we had a delicious breakfast. It is located on a main road and is easy to find. The inn is nicely appointed. We do enjoy the charm of an old historic dwelling and the antique furnishings. Adrienne is friendly and hospitable."