Begin your search for a cheap car rental close to Old Hay Bay Church National Historic Site by keying in your getaway dates and pick-up and drop-off locations. That’s how economical a car rental can be around this popular attraction, but there are a few things that will determine the amount you pay — your travel dates are just the start. Whatever your budget or type of car you want, Expedia has exclusive offers from a wide range of car rental companies that’ll get you in the driver’s seat for less.