You can pick up a cheap car rental close to Shelter Island Whale’s Tail, but several factors will influence the cost of your ride. These include travel dates, pick-up and drop-off locations and extras like a toddler seat. Finding a vehicle that fits your needs and budget is a snap with Expedia. Browse our exclusive offers from a range of car rental companies, and then gear up to discover Shelter Island Whale’s Tail and beyond with your own set of wheels.