Shelter Island Vacations from ₩1,180,214

Great location if your going to Broadway Shows. Staff was friendly. Rooms are tiny but space is at a premium there. No fridge or way to get ice from what I could see if those are things you care about. Probably wouldn't stay there if I was with a family. But if you want to spend less on lodging and need something that gets the job done this is a great place. No issues with my AC or outside noise.

Absolutely no amenities. This is a no frills location. In window air conditioners, no refrigerators etc. The shower was quite bad,clean but maybe 1 foot wide and no conditioner. 2 very small elevators fit maybe 4 or 5 people and there are at least 12 floors. The cleaning crew were blocking the elevators at check in time so there was no way for anyone to use the elevators in a timely manner. The cleaning woman got smart with me. Not everyone has the ability to walk up or down 12 flights of stairs.

The hotel staff are all accommodating, free breakfast have a huge array of choices.

Excellent location in midtown in order to travel north or south of the manhattan. The rooms were large and comfortable, but the lighting in the room was very dim. We sent a note to the manager but there was no response. The only thing that was not good was charging the resort fee which was about $50 a day for amenities that most people in the hotel do not use. Restaurant off the lobby for breakfast and dinner was convenient and the staff were very attentive. However the breakfast was expensive ( $14- $18 for omelette / eggs or yogurt ) and it had a limited menu. We ended up going to various places on Madison which was half the price - eg. Pret n manger. We would stay again.

First, this is a great location, and the staff was extremely friendly and helpful. Room was clean and served it's purpose. My only issue was they didn't have the suite we reserved available on our first night at check-in. The staff was very apologetic and offered to give us a different room for the first night and then move to our reserved room the second day for the remainder of our stay. The issue with this was that while I was traveling with a good friend, we were not the share-a-bed kind of friends, and the room they offered us for the first night had only one queen bed with no options for a rollaway. Our suite we had reserved had a separate bedroom and a pullout in the living room, which was perfect for us. We ended up staying in the alternative room the first night, and there was a recliner which I managed to utilize for sleeping. Once we got our reserved room it was a great stay! My only issue is that they offered me a $200 credit for that first night, but I never saw that credit materialize when I balanced the amount afterward. I just don't have the energy to try and bicker for that credit at this point, but clearly while the staff was super helpful and apologetic, something got missed between the promise and the actual execution. I would stay there again, but I would call ahead to confirm multiple times to make sure the room I have is what I'm getting when I arrive.