We recently stayed at the Cohocton Valley Inn while visiting family. It's a small, family run inn with just a few rooms. It's safe and very quiet. The rooms are clean, comfortable, and have everything you need, but they aren't fancy or updated. The owner is extremely helpful and responsive without being intrusive. It's in a small, quiet town, relatively close to some of the area attractions such as wineries and state parks. For the price point you won't do better in the area.