Tingler Island Vacation Rentals

"This room was a great value. Parking is tough when they’re full. Staff is super nice. They have 24 hour maintenance, nice front desk corks, and a lovely property. Coffee in the lobby, and a nice selection of snacks and toiletries. Beach towels as well. Great location in the keys. "

"Great resort, horrible service at the restaurant. Never checked on us or gave us silverware"

"The staff members were responsive and helpful, but unfortunately the overall experience at the village was very disappointing—especially for a stay of just two nights. The room had a strong humid smell, the sofa was worn out and dirty, and the kitchen was poorly equipped and not well supplied. The unit itself felt very old and outdated, and the window blinds were broken. Overall, the condition of the property did not meet expectations at all."

"Beautiful place with access to their other property. Restaurant on site was excellent, great music at night. Access to marina. Rooms very spacious modern. Pool nice. Breakfast had lots of choices "

"Basically, if you are looking for an extremely pleasing aesthetic, this is your place. Take beautiful pics- the string lights are beautiful, the picture opportunities are amazing. But if you’re wanting to do ANY activities, or hang out on the “beach” this is not the place. Every single thing here (on top of the price per night) is absolutely absurdly expensive. My family is 3 people- me, my husband, and our 11 year old daughter. The scuba would have easily been $1,000 after instructions, equipment rental, and boat rental. The “marketplace” was a joke offering Lululemon at higher prices than online and bathing suits at $275. My daughter found a cute keychain that was a little crochet thing for $35 (the cheapest thing) and then at the register, a bracelet that looks exactly like a bracelet that I bought (coated in gold) for $45 but at the cost of $78. First full day, walked around the 5 pools, main pool, “beach” and couldn’t find a single lounge chair or ANY chair available..PERIOD. Went to the front desk complained and they gave me a cabana for the day (which apparently costs $550/day) no shade, no special treatment. They also gave me 4 free drink tickets, which the drinks were about $20 a piece. So that saved us about $100. The ONE restaurant opens at 9am and closes at 10pm and the bar on the “beach” has bartenders that seem to give zero sh*ts if you’re on vacay. The restaurant haslimited menu options. I have more to say but they cut you off at 1500 words.Would not stay agai"

"Better than I thought- room smelled wet. Great pool views etc "

"Awesome Manager she goes above and beyond normal service, friendly staff."

"For a two night stay, 3 rooms. Totaling over $4,000, what do you think? Worms in room, cockroaches at entrance, toilet paper so thin you might as well use bare fingers, towels that can rub your skin off, service at coffee stand that took forever, noise from across the hall all night. $50 to park my car when already charged over $4,000? Stayed here last five years. Not again."

"Clean and near. Missed opportunities with outside bar and outside bar staff"