Find Historic Hotels in Nantucket Island, MA

Property was very clean and staff were very friendly and helpful.

We hit the Goldmine… We absolutely love staying at this property in Nantucket right off the main path. It was quiet convenient, beautiful area and the really nice place to stay. Absolutely beautiful house and we enjoyed the front porch!

My boyfriend and I had the best overnight at the Madison Inn. The room that we booked was small, but still so comfortable and cute and it was in a really convenient location in the center of Oak Bluffs. Staff was so friendly and awesome. Amazing amenities. Def recommending this place to all of my friends! Looking forward to staying again.

The 21 Broad Hotel is a very comfortable boutique hotel. The service is terrific with a free breakfast and afternoon cocktails. Their downtown location is ideal with easy access to the best dining and only a few blocks from the ferries.

A great stay!! Absolutely no complaints! We’d stay again in the future!!

The Beachside Hotel is a 10 out of 10 and I think it is the best lodging option on Nantucket. 1. Beautiful pool area, excellent service while at pool, plenty of towels etc 2. Food at pool is delicious 3. Arcade is adorable and genius idea 4. The room is perfectly decorated 5. The landscaping is stunning and beautifully maintained 6. The gym has all you need 7. The lobby is unique with cool bar 8. Coffee and donuts in the morning are a nice touch only thing there is maybe to have muffins too...

My sister and I did a few day trip to the Cape and once again stayed here. It is clean and comfortable and I always sleep well! Pam is lovely and accommodating and the queen of muffins. Not fancy, shmancy...but has everything you need/want for a motel and very comfortable. This was our second trip and stay and we will be visiting Pam again!

Really enjoyed our stay. Staff went above and beyond, breakfast was top notch and the Location was great.

Charming Inn with exceptional staff

This is a BEAUTIFUL property. Staff was helpful and friendly, we were in room 16 which I would highly recommend with its double sink and charming view with lenten roses in the window boxes. We had a poor experience at the correlating restaurant via mare, which we would decidedly NOT recommend. I think my only recommendation for management is to run their own restaurant and turn some of that space into a sitting area for guests with tea/coffee.

We loved Hotel Pippa. Wonderful, helpful staff. We especially loved the terrace between the two buildings where we enjoyed breakfast each morning and a glass of wine in the late afternoon. The only thing that could be improved: stronger coffee for the otherwise excellent continental breakfast.

Had a wonderful stay for two nights at this B & B! The owners were so kind and the location was perfect. The only room left for the time we were there had us sharing a bathroom - however we never had any issues with the bathroom being busy/dirty. Our room was next to the bathroom - and we never even heard noise from it. Would stay here again 1000%!

This was my first time on Nantucket and I hope to return - if I do I will definitely be staying at the Seven Sea Street Inn again. The location is perfect and very convenient for the town, whaling museum, shops etc. The inn is spotless and homely. Matt and the team are great at arranging activities/tours and are genuinely interested in their guests enjoyment of the Island. If you need accommodation on the Island, look no further.

Amazing stay!!! We stayed in the Hermit Crab and it was perfect for me and my wife. Plenty big enough with a nice size shower. We will definitely be back!

We had a great stay!! The rooms were so cozy and the location is perfect. The lighthouse is so close by! Great dinning near by! Can't wait to go back!!

Winter or summer, this is our favorite spot to vacation- we love the peaceful, serene atmosphere of the town and Chatham Tides. Main St. has a cute, unique, little stores if shopping is what you enjoy. Property is well kept, ocean view room provides precisely the view that we love to wake up to. Staff is always helpful and accommodating, without being overbearing. Can't wait to return!

The staff at the Jared Coffin house are always the nicest on the island!! I just adore them.