Norwalk Islands Pet-friendly Vacations

The room was OK, but I was charged a deposit prior to check in

We were in the floor 20th. New room. Very clean. Our stay was great

Awesome place, loved my stay. World stay again

Great location - but for the price the condition of the room was appalling. Wallpaper peeling, broken window hinge, outdated TV, very stuffy room.

The PUBLIC Hotel places far more emphasis on its restaurants, bars, and café than on the actual hotel experience. With noticeably limited staff throughout the property, it’s difficult to get timely or consistent customer service. The rooms also lack many standard amenities like bathrobes, slippers, body lotion, and other basic toiletries that you would expect from a hotel in this price range. Overall, the stay felt underwhelming, and I wouldn’t recommend the property, especially when there are many other hotels in NYC that offer a more comfortable and guest-focused experience.

Overall the hotel was good. The room was a good size for NYC and the staff was courteous. Breakfast was just ok. Not many options and service took a really long time.

Lovely staff. Incredible property. The hype is real. This is by far and away the nicest property we’ve stayed at in Manhattan in a long time.

Staff is amazingly nice and helpful.

Rooms left much to be desired. Not a proper placement to room anyone considering rooms were being renovated above which directly affected the plumbing in our room.

The PUBLIC Hotel places far more emphasis on its restaurants, bars, and café than on the actual hotel experience. With noticeably limited staff throughout the property, it’s difficult to get timely or consistent customer service. The rooms also lack many standard amenities like bathrobes, slippers, body lotion, and other basic toiletries that you would expect from a hotel in this price range. Overall, the stay felt underwhelming, and I wouldn’t recommend the property, especially when there are many other hotels in NYC that offer a more comfortable and guest-focused experience.

I had a great stay overall. The staff were friendly and attentive, and the rooms were clean, comfortable, and well-appointed. My overall experience at the hotel was excellent, and the location made it easy to get around and enjoy the area. The only downside was the casino, which felt a bit underwhelming and could use some updates to match the quality of the rest of the property. The casino clearly operates with a strong house edge, and it shows—most games felt noticeably tilted in favor of the house. While the atmosphere is lively, players should be prepared for odds that don’t give them much room to walk away ahead.

We wanted a clean room to sleep. It was quite clean. Out expectations were met. Staff was very nice and helpful. Shared bathroom was not a problem.

Great room and polite staff and excellent restaurant and location.

Excellent room. Big. Well appointed.