City Island, New York hotel rooms at the Fairmont

"All staff were helpful and friendly. Bfast area was excellent and also offered a Happy hour at the bar, a very nice surprise. Great sitting areas to enjoy those free cocktails. Will def return for the price/convenience and all of the above. "

"Absolutely amazing stay from beginning to end. The property was beautiful, clean, and very well maintained. The staff was incredibly friendly, welcoming, and attentive throughout our stay. The room was spotless, comfortable, and had everything we needed. Breakfast and the bar area were both great, and the overall atmosphere made the experience feel relaxing and luxurious. The location was convenient and perfect for exploring the city. I would definitely stay here again and highly recommend this property to anyone visiting!"

"Adrian looked after us at checkin and he was excellent. Ask for room away from stairwell door which bangs loudly. Otherwise, an excellent stay at a lovely reasonably-priced hotel in Manhattan. Great location too."

"Very nice hotel with great rooms (super comfy beds and nice sheets) and a great overall feel including many nice side activities included (yoga, comedy show) - would come back any time "

"I picked the hotel due to location with Madison Square Garden. Hotel was clean, staff very friendly and courteous. Will stay again"

"The location of this hotel is amazing, no question—but it’s a little rough around the edges (e.g., rust spot in the tub, peeling wallpaper, broken shade, broken drawer in nightstand). Also, these rooms are made for TALL people. I’m on the shorter side (5 ft, 4 in.), and there were some things (like the closet) that were a bit challenging. The fitness center is fine, but they have two large televisions with no remote, which was a bummer. But the location is really quite fabulous."

"This is an older hotel, in very good condition. The rooms are smaller than some modern hotels, but we loved it. The location, with the subway 100 feet away, is fantastic. I loved this hotel!"

"Bed sheets were dirty with a huge brown stain in the middle of the sheet. No one came to change it."

"Great easy access to Times Square from this hotel. Short walk to the subway station which was also convenient. The lobby was quite nice, staff was friendly. We found the room a bit dated and needing some cosmetic repairs but worked fine. Would stay again if I wanted to be close to Times Square."