Plum Island, New Jersey hotel rooms at the Highgate Independent

"Mini bar stocked well with water when room was cleaned. Fresh towels etc. There is no breakfast but do have free tea/coffee in the mornings. Staff all super friendly and happy to help. Hotel was in a perfect area for us to explore the city. Overall cleanliness of rooms was disappointing. Stains on carpet and walls, with bathroom needing updated due to mould in grout parts of the shower. Even found a previous customers sock between the bed and air con. "

"Really bad hotel"

"Great staff"

"The rooms are very small yet clean. No microwave in the room, however there is a one in the lobby and each room has a fridge."

"Great for a quick weekend, wish we could have partied on the rooftop"

"The location is great, staff went above and beyond. I think I found my NYC hotel! "

"Great location and size of room. Free breakfast is good too"

"Staff was great, location is very convenient to Subway and shopping. My only complaint was the elevators weren’t working the first day were there. The staff had to operate manually and it took very long to get up to the 36th floor. Would stay again as long as the elevators are working. "

"Great location, clean room, comfortable bed. Great stay an"