Barters Island, Maine hotel rooms at the Independent

"Strange woman that I think was an employee living in the next room over that came knocking on our back slider to say hello to our dog!! room was very dated floor was filthy countertops in room, dusty!"

"Very clean. Walkable to town. Excellent breakfast. Very friendly hosts"

"First thing you would notice is that the Inn is a very old establishment. But don't let the age fool you. The entire building inside and out is A+. The bathroom which should in my opinion should be the telltale as to how everything is maintained. Our room was on a 1 to 10 was at the very least a 20! The room rates are affordable, the staff very welcoming. Highly recommended and we will stay here whenever we are in town."

"Fantastic location in town. Hotel is very clean and rooms were comfortable. Def will return."

"The room was very clean and neat the heat air air-conditioning worked great."

"It’s a little bit hard to try and describe this place, but I will tell you I have enjoyed my stays the people that worked there a friendly. The staff at the counter are good to work with very friendly people. I have not been all the time that I’ve stayed there and I think I’ve lost count cannot complain. It’s it’s just a nice place to stay and the people there are very well mannered and very nice to deal with. I’ve never had a problem."

"Beautiful hotel, central location"

"The breakfast was good everything was hot and fresh."

"April 2026, the Comfort Inn is open but is undergoing full renovations. This was not mentioned when we made our reservations. If you have allergies you, or low tolerance of, construction dust, choose another location. We had a newly renovated room, which was spotless and very comfortable. The staff were polite and efficient, and breakfast at 6am has always been good. We’ve stayed here multiple times over the last 10+ years. Giving full stars because the renovations will end soon."