Randall's Island 4 Stars Hotels

Clean and great staff

Convenient location; pleasant staff. Confused about cost of breakfast. Thought it was included, but was charged a large amount for the meals.

This hotel is fantastic. The breakfast, staff, and rooms are really nice.

Great spot for a first time trip to NYC, was close to everything and the hotel was amazing from top to bottom. Couldn't have asked for a better stay.

Miki Santiago and the whole team were terrific- thank you.

This was a beautiful property with amazing customer service! Karma helped us with check in and check out which were both very smooth processes

Nice bakery for breakfast.

We have been to New York City many many times over the years. This hotel was our very favorite overall. We stayed at fancier ones. We’ve stayed at National chains. The personal care and attention you get from everyone at Hotel Scherman has been unsurpassed. While my husband would have preferred bacon and eggs biscuits and gravy for breakfast, the kids and I were very happy with the complementary continental breakfast. The walk ability to Broadway shows and Times Square was wonderful. We never...

I stayed here recently with my husband and daughters and it was perfect! The staff was friendly and helpful, the room was clean and comfortable and the location was absolutely perfect! They had even upgraded us to a suite!! We had absolutely no complaints and will be staying here again on our next visit!

Travel to NY often. The Arlo always is a great stay. Clean, smells amazing, good vibes, friendly/stylish staff, great decor, reasonably priced. Just do it. Stay here. Perfect for solo travel.

The only thing I didn't like was the parking situation, but understand it's NYC and parking isn't always convenient.

The hotel was close to restaurants and easy to access transit system.

Great location! Great restaurants nearby! Comfortable beds. It would have been nice though if a little birthday card or something was put in my room! Other than that you cannot go wrong staying here and I’m planning to again!

I really enjoyed my stay. If you're looking for a quiet place - this is not it, though. You can hear the street noise. It's New York, after all. Just mentioning this as I noticed it, but quickly got used to it. The location is great. Near subways, restaurants, Broadway. Almost everything is walking distance away. The room is good and a welcome respite from the busy-ness of the city, but we didn't spend much time in it, because there is just way too much to see and do and too little time.

A nautical themed hotel (trust me, it's cool), that is across the street from the NYC Google office. Breakfast is basic but good and free. Lots of good restaurants are nearby

The only problem I had was the staff complained when I brought Dunkin Donuts coffee from across the street into the lobby. I’m sorry but when I’m spending $4,000 for a trip I feel like I can get my coffee from anywhere I please They kept saying no outside food or drink

My stay was nothing short of amazing. Every time I visit New York, I try to stay here. During my most recent visit, I was pleasantly welcomed by trainees at the front desk who were both friendly and professional. Elijah, in particular, stood out he was very knowledgeable and made the check-in process smooth and enjoyable.

This was an amazing place to stay. EVERYONE is friendly. The room is clean. The bed is huge and comfortable. The air gets so cold. The rooftop bar has BEAUTIFUL views of the city. The location is perfect. You're so close to EVERYTHING! The staff is knowledgeable and happy to help. The atmosphere is so chill. It's a nice, quiet stay compared to the hustle and bustle of the city. I love the atmosphere. Would definitely stay again. Also. The rooms are SO quiet. We were right next to the elevator,...

Very centrally located. Amazing staff and clean. My go to place for New York